The metaphysical nature of debt
(3:06)
What can any European Country do to sustain its own inefficiency without going bankrupt? To spend more than it collects? Once upon a time, in extreme cases such a country would simply have
devalued its currency. All of the Country’s citizens simply became 20% to 30% poorer. Exports increate due to the more competitive pricing of the Country’s goods. The people tightened their belts and everything went on as normal. The advent of the
Euro meant that this type of thing was no longer possible, however, increasing the level of public debt by issuing more
Government Bonds has remained a viable option. To all intents and purposes, Government Bonds have replaced the ability to print more money. The product to debt ratio is a good indicator of a nation’s health. The less it produces and the more it gets into debt, the closer the Country comes to
bankruptcy.
The issuing of debt by means of government bonds has no limit, as long as someone is prepared to buy the bonds and the government is able to meet its interest payment commitments and pay back the monetary value when the bonds expire. If public finances decline, as in the case of the so-called
PIIGS, the interest payable on government bonds already issued increases and the number of buyers decreases due to the increased risk of default. If the PIIGS fail, then their creditors, namely the virtuous Countries of northern Europe, could also fail in turn. The European banks in Germany, Holland and France, which are indebted to the tune of hundreds of billions of Euro, would be totally swept away should
Italy or Spain ever default.
There is something truly diabolical about the issuing of debt and its calculation. The creation of debt is totally beyond the control of the average man in the street. In the past year, for example,
Tremorti has managed to increase the Italian population’s level of debt by around one hundred billion Euro, without asking or saying anything to anyone. He then sold this debt on, partly to the very same Italians that he plunged into debt in the first place (the perfect 69, isn’t it?), and the rest he spread around the entire planet. The security of the debt lies in the apparent security of the government bonds. Their yield may well be lower than that of other investments, but they are deemed to be a safe investment. It would appear that the reimbursement of the face value of the government bonds at the time of expiry is guaranteed, which is not true in the case of shares traded on the Stock Exchange, which are subject to market fluctuations. Government bonds, in other words the purchase of third party debt, are somewhat like a
totem pole: a State cannot fail. This popular belief enables Countries to sell off their debt, thereby enabling them to make yet more debt. If a Country fails, it usually loses all of its invested capital in one fell swoop due to so-called "debt restructuring ", which is a nice way of saying that the parties that purchased the debt are left standing in their underpants.
In order to avert bankruptcy, Europe has agreed to buy up any government bonds issued by the
PIIGS that would otherwise have gone unsold. For this purpose, Europe needs the
750 billion Euro that have already been allocated (not enough according to many analysts). This in order to buy up any debt made by reckless governments. The myth of intangible government bonds that will be bought back in any event upon expiry must be eliminated once and for all. A Country should be assessed in the same manner as one would assess any public shareholder company, in other words, if its financial value drops, its share value for the shareholder must drop accordingly. Investments would then focus more on the creation of value rather than its destruction. Making debt is something done by the reckless, selling it off is something
metaphysical and purchasing such debt is an act of pure folly.
Ps. The Friends of Beppe Grillo in Roma wish to advise that the hearing scheduled for 12 May, in the trial of Warrant Officer Vincenzo Lo Zito, has been postponed for reasons of legitimate impediment, being the non-availability of the Warrant Officer's defence attorney to attend the hearing. A new date for the hearing will be announced shortly.
Posted by Beppe Grillo at 08:54 AM in Economics
| Comments
(6) | Comments in Italian (translated)
Post a comment
| Sign up
| Send to a friend |
| GrilloNews
|
Listen
|
View blog opinions
|
|
Condividi
Comments
Peppino, thank you very much. Michael Hudson's article is absolutely precise and simple in describing the current situation. I'll translate the article in italian and spread it for the largely unaware italian audience...
Posted by: luca forcolini | May 15, 2010 10:51 AM
The BP spill in the Gulf of Mexico is an environmental holocaust happening under our very eyes, and all we can do is watch the ocean as it continues to be covered by a thick, rusty-colored blanket of oil. The life-killing crude keeps on gushing. Why? Because we believed the reassuring bullshit BP told concerned environmental organizations. Things, they said, would always be under control. Now, the nightmarish scenario BP was warned about is reality and BP has nothing under control. While these corporations were quick enough to figure out how to extract oil from hell, they are as ignorant as I am about capping the gusher. The fuckers are even joking about what they've done: they want to stuff the hole with golf balls! Had I caused the destruction of one of the most beautiful coastlines and marshes in the world, suffocated dolphins, and destroyed marine life vital to the life and culture of millions of people, you know what would have happened? They would have shoved me down that very same hole beneath the ocean floor. But to the CEOs of British Petroleum, Halliburton and Transocean, Obama fines them one cent per barrel of oil they extract. They can't stop laughing. BP's first quarter profits this year were over 100 billion dollars. People can't even wrap their heads around that amount of money - that's the equivalent of 66 wagons, each one loaded with 35 tons of 100 dollar bills. It's fucking mindboggling! One would think that with that kind of money BP would go to the people and clear away their concerns about their future. No fucking way! The CEOs, instead blame blame one another: BP's Lamar McKay (general contractor), blames Tim Probert of Halliburton (platform) who, in turn, blames Steven Newman of Transocean (drilling). Praying, In the meantime, media's short attention span will make us forget the nightmare.
Posted by: louis Pacella | May 13, 2010 03:30 PM
I still contend that in the EU there is some creation of money out of thin air made by banks allowed to have 40-60 leverage ratios investing in assets (sovereign debt) considered "too safe to fail". We are not bailing out any of the PIGS countries, we are just and again bailing out those banks which lent to governments. The latter are just allowing them to manage their assets and liabilities with such high ratios and make bigger profits. In this way the Ponzi scheme goes on.
http://mgiannini.blogspot.com/2010/05/too-interconnected-to-fail.html
Posted by: M.G. in Progress | May 12, 2010 02:31 PM
In a phrase, Socialism/Communism is dead. They don't work. If you don't believe me check out both the European stock markets and above all the Euro. There are no entitlement programs. You're entitled to what you can produce.
Bye bye EU, bye bye Euro!!!
Posted by: David B. Monier-Williams | May 12, 2010 02:24 PM
The metaphysical nature of debt is a very good presentation of the problems presenting the EURO, but does not dare to present even a tentative solution.
Europe has designed a currency that cannot be devalued and therefore without self correction, and leave two options:
1)Save and cut programs so to pay the debt. This is impossible, most of the GDP goes to pay the interests !
2)Keep selling bonds until is it possible, increasing the debt more and more. eventually the system cracks.
Does Beppe Grillo, the 5 stars movement, the European Central Bank have a solution to propose ?
In a couple of years we shall be back in the same situation, only worse. It would seems to be a case of back to the drafting board for the EURO.
Posted by: Victor Ximenes | May 12, 2010 11:11 AM
For an enlightened overview of the 'problem' of Greece, and other EU countries, see
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article25422.htm
Posted by: Peppino Vallesi | May 12, 2010 09:30 AM