The Euro’s up in smoke


“The Eurozone chess game has entered its third and final stage. Germany wins in three moves - Euro, deflation and purchase of public debt by the ECB (QE) – and in the last few years it has found a way to maximise its profits and reduce to zero its risks as Europe’s creditor.

Germany’s risks
Let’s try analysing the problems of the Eurozone as they really are: problems of conflicting interests of creditors and debtors regulated by demand and supply. If you agree to make a loan to your neighbour, you open yourself up to three risks:
• that he’ll pay you back in a different currency that has perhaps been devalued unless you had a prior agreement about the repayment currency (currency risk);
• that with the amount you get back, you can buy fewer goods or property (inflation risk);
• that you don’t even have either of the first two problems because your neighbour simply goes bust and thus you lose everything (capital risk).

How Germany gains
Germany is the Eurozone’s only big creditor with about 600 billion Euro loaned to various countries, most of which are on the periphery of the Eurozone, including Italy. The Euro has given it this enviable status. If you produce lots and you consume and invest very little and you keep domestic wages and prices low, then you’ll always have cheap unconsumed goods to sell to your neighbours. And you might also be able to make money by providing credit that they will probably ask you for so that they can buy your goods that are so cheap and so good. This is Germany’s situation. It has always had this approach to the market economy in European affairs ever since 1870 with its roots in Calvinism. Thus to sell and lend to the countries on the periphery of Europe was always Germany’s preferred economic activity when everything was going well, before the crisis in 2008. Since then its only objective has been to get that credit returned and to protect its purchasing power.


Germany’s checkmate
Basically, QE will give Germany the time needed to achieve the final objective needed to get checkmate: to get rid of the national jurisdiction over as much of the debt as possible and thus to reduce its own capital risk as much as possible. Only the debt issued under Italian jurisdiction can be redefined in a new currency and thus could impose losses on foreign creditors, mainly German, via devaluation of the new currency. Today that proportion stands at about 93%. So only 7%, not more than 150 billion of public debt, cannot be redefined and has to be paid by in Euro, in accordance with the contract. Assuming that there’ll be devaluation of 30%, implies that the cost of a Euroexit for Italy in relation to its public debt, would have been no greater than about 50 billion euro before QE. With the de facto QE, this number has gone up to about 80 billion given that if there’s a collapse, the cost of a “haircut” of let’s say 30% on 100 billion government bonds (BTP) that would be bought by the Bank of Italy, would be a cost borne by all of us. In the eyes of a German creditor, restructuring our debt or an exit with the devaluation of the new currency, in fact present the same capital risk.
So, from now on, the only thing that counts for us Italians in the game of ‘creditor v debtor’ is not to lose jurisdiction over our debt, so that we maintain the right to redefine it. This means we get the benefit if we do exit. Germany’s objective is exactly the opposite: remove our jurisdiction over our debt and thus increase the cost of an exit for us and give the advantage to them, thus continuing to protect the interests of the creditors, which is something it’s really good at.
If we wait too long before leaving the Euro, then Germany will get checkmate and after cashing in all the benefits of our entry into the Euro, it will also cash in on the benefits of our exit.

Posted by Beppe Grillo at 03:34 PM in | Comments (4) | Comments in Italian (translated) Post a comment | Sign up | Send to a friend | | GrilloNews | listen_it_it.gifListen |
View blog opinions
| | Condividi



ISDA claim of default (which may or may not be claimed in the event of redenomination of Italian debt into Lira) **is another possible outcome, but really only matters in determining whether CDS payouts occur. **

Posted by: Jon | February 20, 2015 09:50 PM


Italy, Greece, etc. can just default on debt "out of their jurisdiction". If they did the only conceivable loss would be any restrictions to re-market debt in the foreign jurisdiction again depending on the covenants(the Argentina/US problem). Better legal environments can fetch lower interest rates.

ISDA claim of default (which may or may not be claimed in the event of redenomination of Italian debt into Lira.

The real question is whether international creditors (with or without an ISDA credit event designation) will punish Italian rates in a currency move to *the same extent* as an outright default. If they did than it wouldn't matter if Italy also then defaulted on debt outside of its legal jurisdiction.

But the big checkmate for Greece/Italy/etc. against Germany comes in that (Lira/Drachma aside) there is **no** internal consequences for a country on defaulting on its official sector debt. If Italy defaults on it's private sector debt than it's banks, pensions, etc. suffer which may or may not need to be bailed out.

If Italy defaults on its official sector debt they stiff German taxpayers and a central bank no longer their own. And thanks to the Eurozone illegally claiming that official sector debt could be segregated from a Greek default... a periphery nation can now claim that a default of *only* the official sector debt is legally acceptable (again assuming they're moving to own currency). That means that Greece and Italy can just void all of their official sector debt and keep only their private sector debt (to the delight of bondholders) and the Eurozone can't do anything about it.

The checkmate against the German taxpayers is about to (and should) happen.

Posted by: Jon | February 20, 2015 09:46 PM

What about a default, Mr. Grillo? What would Germany still get from a default before exit?

Posted by: Gigel Chiazna | February 20, 2015 04:38 PM

I have been following your Blog for sometime now, I think you are a great man, and your efforts in Italy, have been the best thing that has ever happened in Italian and Europe politically ever.
However I believe that if anything is to really change in Italy, the Italians need to be educated to matters that effect and control the planet, and need to know about the New World Order the Jesuits the Vatican the Cabal and the hold they have over us all. The multinationals, chemtrailing, the industrial weapons machine, the pharmasuitical industry etc. Until the Italians have understood the control system and how they use people like Obama, Renzie, Berlusconi etc. they will never understand the problem. So my suggestion is more info on the matters I have raised above. Let your people Know, with more knowledge we may succeed in having a better more just world.

Posted by: Vittoria London | February 19, 2015 09:25 AM

Post a comment

Beppe Grillo's Blog is an open space for you to use so that we can come face to face directly. As your comment is published immediately, there's no time for filters to check it out. Thus the Blog's usefulness depends on your cooperation and it makes you the only ones responsible for the content and the resulting outcomes.

Information to be read before using Beppe Grillo's Blog

The following are not allowed:
1. messages without the email address of the sender
2. anonymous messages
3. advertising messages
4. messages containing offensive language
5. messages containing obscene language
6. messages with racist or sexist content
7. messages with content that constitutes a violation of Italian Law (incitement to commit a crime, to violence, libel etc.)

However, the owner of the Blog can delete messages at any moment and for any reason.
The owner of the Blog cannot be held responsible for any messages that may damage the rights of third parties Maximum comment length is 2,000 characters.
If you have any doubts read "How to use the blog".

Post a comment (English please!)

First name and Surname*:

Email Address*:
We remind you that anonymous messages (without real first name and surname) will be cancelled.

* Compulsory fields

Send to a friend

Send this message to *

Your Email Address *

Message (optional)

* Compulsory fields

Beppe Grillo Meetups

Groups 372 Members 76.596
Cities 281 Countries 10

Books and DVDs


Check out the books and DVDs of Beppe Grillo (service in Italian)


Clean Up Parliament

Map of Power


Webby award
14th Annual Webby Awards Official Honoree Selections


Tegenlicht - Beppe Grillo's Interview

"De toekomst van Europa volgens Beppe Grillo"

(Tegenlicht TV)

International Press Review

The New Yorker
"Beppe's Inferno"

"The Comic Who Shook Italy"
(The video | Related post)

"The Web Celeb 25"
(Related post)

"Meeting Italy's silenced satirist"

People and power: "Beppe's Blog"

TIME magazine's First Annual Blog Index
(related post)